(717) 263-6360

Click the people

Auto.

Click the people

The comforting face of experience.

40 years of
great support.

Since 1982, Shoemaker’s insurance
has existed to create peace of
mind for families and businesses
by delivering personal service and
superior professional advice.

Precisely sized guidance.

The Insurance Advisor approach puts
you in the right direction by offering
direct answers to questions such as,
‘What coverage do I really need?’ ‘What
are the risks?’ ‘How will it affect me?’
How much coverage is enough?
what is the cost?

Smooth transitions.

Switching, reviewing, enrolling or
filing a claim are all smooth
processes here! Even the least
experienced has no problems
fitting into better benefits!

Insurance with a sole soul.

A TAIL OF COMPASSION!

The plight of homeless, neglected, and distressed animals in our area is more than just statistics; it’s a call to action that we’ve answered by partnering with Cumberland Valley Animal Shelter (CVAS). This partnership reflects our shared values and commitment to not only provide shelter but also to heal, love, and find forever homes for these innocent creatures. CVAS’s dedication mirrors our own, aiming to create a ripple of positive change throughout Newville and beyond.

Going the extra mile -
pure appreciation!

Loyalty is highly rewarded here with
constant easy-to-win opportunities
to score big prizes and benefit
community folks we care about, too!

To kick back and read.

A monthly connection to
life-enriching tips.

Strolling around town.

A Concierge Program that shares top
local contacts and serves as a reliable
field guide.Community businesses
are happy to be featured and
supported. Need a service? Got
suggestions?

Click the people

The team at Shoemaker's is phenomenal. They always answer our questions with ease and provide wonderful service. A great company!!
Meagan Hammond
Meagan Hammond
Very convenient and friendly!!
Steve Dawson
Steve Dawson
Kiera has always been very supportive with anything and everything I've asked of her.
Gary Horton
Gary Horton
Sara Rhine in commercial insurance and Owner Nathan Shoemaker's team for personal and healthcare insurance redefine excellence. Sara's expertise and dedication ensure tailored solutions for businesses, while Nathan's team goes above and beyond in personalized care.Sara Rhine is a true standout in commercial insurance, providing unmatched expertise and dedication. She crafts solutions that precisely meet the unique needs of each business, instilling confidence in her clients.Nathan Shoemaker and his team excel in personal and healthcare insurance, offering a level of care that's truly exceptional. They go beyond policies, understanding and addressing the individual health goals and financial situations of their clients.If you're looking for insurance professionals who combine industry expertise with genuine care, Shoemakers Insurance is the answer. Sara Rhine and Nathan Shoemaker's team set a standard of excellence that truly stands out in the insurance landscape. Highly recommended!
Natalie Crawford
Natalie Crawford
I had some friends that were notified of a Medicare change and needed to get new coverage and recommended them to Stacey at shoemakers insurance all of them have told me that the service she provided was
Train Strong
Train Strong
Stacy was amazing. She listened to my needs and made suggestions that were both affordable and the best options. She understood my situation and helped me make the right decisions for my current lifestyle.Highly recommend this company, and specifically, Stacy!
debra newcomer
debra newcomer
I can always count on a response. I am comfortable that they will stand behind any claims. They are local and easy to communicate with.
Randy Meals
Randy Meals
The staff at Shoemakers Insurance are always friendly and knowledgeable. They will work to get you the best rate on the coverage you need.
Missi Elliott
Missi Elliott
This nationwide office cares about its customers and reach out to make sure that they are providing the proper services to us as well as making sure we are getting the most value as possible.Great friendly customer service, kiera in mcconnellsburg pa office is awesome , quick efficient and very knowledgeable. Whenever there is a issue she is willing to assist, I did switch service providers a while back , but came back because nothing compares to the staff in the mcconellsburg office.
John Deross
John Deross
Stacy Runyon made my appointment today so easy and stress free. She is wonderful to work with.
Deb Kissel
Deb Kissel
Shoemakers has been both our personal and commercial agent for many years! They're always there when we need them. They go above and beyond to help with my many demands (and changes to policies). Thank you Kiera, Anna and of course Nathan!
Charity Frye
Charity Frye
Very helpful staff, always do title work here!
uncle sam huber
uncle sam huber
Stacey helped me find a new insurance that best fitted my needs. As a diabetic who takes a lot of meds she was able to find me an insurance that I pay a fraction of the price for all the meds and also I have no premiums. The other insurance I paid approximately $200 a month and that was just to have the insurance. I pay nothing now, I save that every month and my meds are cheaper. Thank you so much Stacey. I am recommending you to all my friends.
Kim Clever
Kim Clever
Very helpful. I had a problem with a title I didn't know about. They found the problem and are fixing it.
Glenn Gayman Jr
Glenn Gayman Jr
You take care of your customers. Always friendly and very helpful. Thank you for the help you have given us.Bill & April Barber
William Barber
William Barber
Stacy Runyon is extremely knowledgeable about health insurance. And makes the process so simple. I refer her to everyone I know!
Rachel Deimler
Rachel Deimler
Stacy has been a tremendous help and guide. Extremely pleasant and knowledgeable and able to answer all our questions. She always makes herself available.
Corey Tornetta
Corey Tornetta
Superior customer service & very professional
Stephanie Mellinger
Stephanie Mellinger
Best prices and service around!
Kim Raffensberger
Kim Raffensberger
These guys are great. We already had car insurance and homeowners (I think) with them when we were looking for new flood insurance. We got our property surveyed, or whatever it is that you do, and found that the flood line was only a tiny portion of our basement. But our insurance guy said we would still have to pay $2,800 a year, so he did not want to send it to FEMA. I called Shoemaker’s and they ran it through FEMA and it was $800 and some change for the year. I asked if that was for real and he assured me it was. We saved $2,000 and they were wonderful when I was having a meltdown lol! Thank you so much.
Lisa Dynarski
Lisa Dynarski
They always follow thru on all of my question
Donald Kuhn
Donald Kuhn
I’ve already referred others and they had the same great experience
Pat Glass
Pat Glass
Always a pleasure working with Nathan!
Jessica Burdge
Jessica Burdge
I am always greeted with a hello and a smile everytime I go in to pay my insurance. If I have any questions, they always have answers.I am very happy with the service they provide.
Pauline Carlin
Pauline Carlin
They help they customers
Gloria Holloway
Gloria Holloway
Very happened with my policy they're very good people
Kimberly Creighton
Kimberly Creighton
Personal and friendly, as well as knowledgeable.
Judy Orth
Judy Orth
I Love Sara Rhine at Shoemaker's Insurance, she is amazing.!!
Philicia Muldrow-Lewis
Philicia Muldrow-Lewis
Stacey at Shoemaker's Insurance is amazing! Two years ago when my insurance changed I was blessed to be connected with Stacey! She was so thorough and helped me find the very best policy for my situation.Then recently my family in NC desperately needed help with their insurance and I mentioned the help I received from Stacey. Even though they aren't in Pa.she took her time to find someone in NC. that would be as helpful. She was spot-on with her recommendation! My daughter said several times today "how is this possible?' Thank you so much Stacey. I so appreciate you. You are incredible!
Diana Sheffield
Diana Sheffield
Great people & great service! They looked at all the details and made sure my business was properly insured.
JJAMAL HOLDINGS
JJAMAL HOLDINGS
All the staff is kind and very patience! They are very knowledgeable and helpful in helping you make your insurance decisions! I recommend them for your insurance needs!
Todd Burkholder
Todd Burkholder
Nationwide since I started driving now home and auto
Sherry Coble
Sherry Coble
Great service and friendly staff! Thanks so much for helping my Dad and me!!
Roxy Darius
Roxy Darius
If you need help in finding an affordable health plan on Pennie, I highly recommend working with Stacy Runyon, who is a certified Pennie agent. She is very knowledgeable about the different insurance options available and will assist you in filling out the often confusing application form. She helped me find great medical and dental plans, saving me a lot of time and money. Plus I have peace of mind in knowing that my application was filled out correctly, and she is a great resource if I have any further questions.
Laura Ksycewski
Laura Ksycewski
Stacy was very thorough with all our Medicare Insurance selections & prescription needs. Excellent follow up care!
Susan Neill
Susan Neill
Stacy Runyon was very helpful when we were looking for the best Medicare insurance for my husband and I. She showed us what we had and what we could get for a much lower premium. She knew what she was selling.
Vicki Bailey
Vicki Bailey
Big shout out to Stacy Runyon! She was extremely helpful when we were searching for health coverage on the exchange. Stacy was very knowledgeable and of great assistance to us. If not her following up with us at end of the year, we may have missed the enrollment period. Thank you Stacy. We look forward to working with you in the future when getting ready for Medicare. Definitely recommend!
Dennis Jungman
Dennis Jungman
Everyone I've worked with at Shoemaker's (insurance needs) had been courteous, helpful and dedicated to getting me the answers and service I needed.
Michael Purnell
Michael Purnell
Recently needed to file a claim and the staff were very helpful.
Joyce Benedict
Joyce Benedict
I've been with Nationwide for over 40 years, and they've been WITH me through all that. The last six have been with Shoemakers, and they have been WITH us through some difficult times too. Great folks, thoroughly knowledgable and capable, and more than willing to go "more than the extra mile", too.
Robert Ranck
Robert Ranck
Friendly service.
Travis Zook
Travis Zook
everything!!!
Darryl Burd
Darryl Burd
Always there with you need them and responsive to your needs!
Ethel Bateman
Ethel Bateman
I have been doing business with them for quite a few years. I have always had great service ( including after hours. )They have always treated me like I'm there best coustomer.Would recommend giving them a call.
Joe Linhard
Joe Linhard
Finding the right insurance can be confusing Stacy helped us make the right decisions for our family. The entire team was very friendly and patient. Thank you for your Help, Bill & April Barber.
William Barber
William Barber
Extremely helpful
Mitch Carr
Mitch Carr
Awesome the ladies are so helpful.
Zody Hershey
Zody Hershey
Great service and friendly staff. FYI CASH ONLY
Dakota boyles
Dakota boyles
Very personable staff
Ron Richards
Ron Richards
Absolutely the best I love the tracking they have and discounts and the low prices
Jefferson Monroe
Jefferson Monroe

Step in with confidence.

For protection that always fits!

If you want to go far, here is where you start.

Let the journey begin!

115 Fairfield St.
Newville, PA 17241

165 E. Washington St.
Chambersburg, PA 17201

644 Lincoln Way E.
McConnellsburg, PA 17233