INDEPENDENT INSURANCE

About Us

Coverage that Follows Your Footsteps

Providing personal and business insurance solutions to residents across PA and beyond.

How can we help today?

Personal Insurance

Business Insurance

Insurance Quotes

Shoemaker’s Insurance

Who we are

At our privately owned insurance agency, our values are rooted in family, personalized care, and a drive to constantly improve.

Being independent means we can offer a wide range of options, tailoring insurance plans specifically to suit your individual needs. We take care of the logistics, guide you through every life stage, and keep your best interests at heart.

With our knowledgeable team by your side, you’re not just getting insurance—you’re gaining a trusted partner committed to helping you understand your options and make confident decisions.

Home | Shoemaker's Insurance

Our Team of Professionals

Our committed team of insurance professionals is focused on securing coverage that fits your specific needs. We take pride in delivering outstanding, comprehensive service—from setting up your policy to providing attentive support when it matters most during the claims process.

Nathan Shoemaker

President / CEO

Kiera Keefer

Personal Lines Manager

Kelsey Shoemaker

Associate Agent

Kari Dillman

Lisenced Agent

Stacy Runyon

Life & Health Agent

Anna Shipley

Commercial & Agribusiness Agent

Sabrina Knepper

Associate Agent

Savannah Frederick

Associate Agent

Trish Grove

Hina Basheer

Client relations associate

Shoemaker’s Insurance

Working with us has its advantages

Tailored insurance solutions that understand your community’s needs.

We provide options to find the best coverage at the best price.
We continuously analyze the marketplace to meet your evolving needs.
We stand by you, offering objective advice and support whenever you need it.

Explore your insurance options.

Shoemaker’s Insurance offers a wide range of personal and business insurance solutions to residents and businesses across PA and beyond. Explore our coverage options and connect with a team member to get a personalized quote today!

All Personal Insurance Info

All Business Insurance Info

Here’s what our clients are saying

 ” I am always greeted with a hello and a smile everytime I go in to pay my insurance. If I have any questions, they always have answers. I am very happy with the service they provide. “

Pauline C., Google Review

” Very helpful. I had a problem with a title I didn’t know about. They found the problem and are fixing it. “

Glenn G., Google Review

” I have been doing business with them for quite a few years. I have always had great service ( including after hours. ) They have always treated me like I’m there best customer. Would recommend giving them a call. “

Joe L., Google Review

” Personal and friendly, as well as knowledgeable “

Judy O., Google Review

” Everyone I’ve worked with at Shoemaker’s (insurance needs) had been courteous, helpful and dedicated to getting me the answers and service I needed. “

Michael P., Google Review

Areas we Service

We’re dedicated to serving you with personalized insurance solutions. We’re here to meet your insurance needs in Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware, Ohio, Virginia, West Virginia, Florida, Georgia, and Tennessee. Reach out to a knowledgeable agent today!

Shoemaker's Insurance Pennsylvania
Shoemaker's Insurance Logo

Headquarters

165 E Washington
St Chambersburg PA 17201

717-263-6360

Send us a Message!